by MyRide^ » Wed Sep 12, 2007 7:41 am
Did the dealer check your rotors for runout? Because the rotors should be dumped only if they are below minimum safe thickness, have scores deeper than 0.060", have parallelism or are warped.
If the rotors were damaged some way, then yes, they totally have to be replaced and the pads with them. Do this one big service, then keep up on your brake maintenance. So long as you replace the pads inside the particular service interval and your wheels are generally torqued properly, you will be able to avoid replacing the rotors again for quite some time.
Unfortunately, there are some cases where the rotors can not be machined with an on the car brake lathe BMW's, for example, have prisoner rotors that can not be machined on the car due to dust shield . An on the car lathe is the only way to correct parallelism in the rotors. But I could get a second opinion at an independent shop that specializes in Audi.they may quote you a more reasonable price, although the dealer is offering you the just going rate. do not dump a good car because of one $900 bill.